1Password Review: Is It Worth Paying For? (Compared to Bitwarden, Dashlane, NordPass & Proton Pass)
Disclosure: this review contains affiliate links. If you sign up through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you — see our full disclosure. We only recommend tools we've genuinely evaluated.
The problem: you know you should stop reusing passwords, and you still haven’t
Everyone who ends up shopping for a password manager arrives the same way: not because they woke up wanting better security hygiene, but because something forced the issue. A “this password was found in a data breach” warning from a browser. A locked-out account after a phishing attempt on a family member. A new job that requires MFA and a managed vault. Whatever the trigger, the research that follows usually turns into an afternoon of open tabs comparing five tools that all claim to be the most secure, the easiest to use, and the best value — often in the same paragraph.
The honest starting point is that the core function — generating and storing strong, unique passwords behind one master password — is table stakes across all five tools below. None of them are insecure in any way that should worry you. Where they actually diverge is in how the encryption is architected, how sharing works for a household or small team, and — this turned out to be the most consistently underreported part of researching this category — what you actually pay once the signup discount expires.
That last point deserves a flag up front: password manager pricing pages are some of the most promotion-driven in software. Several of the tools below advertise a low headline number that only applies to a specific term length for new customers, with the standard renewal rate published nowhere obvious on the site. That’s not a reason to avoid any of them, but it is a reason to read the “what you pay after year one” section before entering a card number.
Three things that actually matter when you’re choosing
1. How the encryption is actually architected, not just described. Every tool here claims “zero-knowledge encryption,” and that claim is true across the board in the sense that the vendor can’t read your vault. The real differences are in the details: whether the client apps are open-source and independently auditable, whether there’s a second secret (beyond your master password) required to decrypt data, and which encryption standard is used. These details matter more than marketing copy, because they determine what happens in the worst case — a server breach, a subpoena, or a compromised employee account at the vendor.
2. The sharing and family model. A password manager bought for one person and a password manager bought for a household or a small team are different purchases, even when the marketing page treats them as a single upsell. Some tools bundle multiple accounts into one family price; others charge per seat with no volume break until you hit a “Teams” tier built for businesses, not families. Get this wrong and you either overpay for seats nobody uses or hit a wall the day a second family member wants their own vault.
3. What the price actually is at renewal, not at signup. This is the criterion that took the most digging to get right, and it’s worth explaining why: several vendors in this category display dynamically-generated prices that change by region, by term length (1-year vs. 2-year), and by whether you’re a new or returning customer — sometimes without showing a plain “$X/month” figure anywhere on the page. A tool that looks like the cheapest option at checkout can end up costing more than a competitor once the first-term discount rolls off.
What you get for free, before paying anything
This is where the category splits more sharply than the pricing pages suggest:
| Tool | Free plan | Key limitation |
|---|---|---|
| 1Password | None — 14-day trial only, then mandatory payment | No ongoing free option at all, unlike every other tool here |
| Bitwarden | Yes — unlimited passwords, cross-device sync, share with one other person | No file attachments or emergency access without Premium |
| Dashlane | None — the free plan was discontinued in September 2025; existing free users were migrated to a Premium trial that has since expired | New signups go straight to a paid plan |
| NordPass | Yes — unlimited passwords | Can only stay logged in on one device at a time; logging into a second device signs you out of the first |
| Proton Pass | Yes — unlimited logins, 10 email aliases for masked signups | Password health/breach monitoring and advanced sharing are Plus-only |
The practical upshot: if trying before buying matters to you, Bitwarden, NordPass, and Proton Pass all let you actually use the product indefinitely at no cost. 1Password and Dashlane don’t — with 1Password, budget for a subscription from day one; the 14-day trial is a look, not a long-term option.
How they compare on price
| Tool | Entry paid price | Family/sharing option | Encryption approach |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1Password | $3.99/mo billed monthly, or $2.99/mo on the (new-customer, first-year) annual rate | Families: $5.99/mo monthly, $4.49/mo annual — up to 5 members | AES-256-GCM + a locally-stored 128-bit Secret Key that never leaves your device |
| Bitwarden | $1.65/mo, billed annually only ($19.80/year) | Families: $3.99/mo billed annually ($47.88/year) — up to 6 accounts | AES-256, fully open-source clients and server, self-hosting available |
| Dashlane | Around $4.99/mo billed annually | Friends & Family: around $7.49/mo billed annually — up to 10 accounts | AES-256, proprietary client, includes a bundled VPN on paid tiers |
| NordPass | List annual rate around $2.99/mo ($35.88/year) — frequently discounted lower for new customers on 1- or 2-year terms | Family: roughly $3.69-4/mo on promotional terms — up to 6 users | XChaCha20, a newer, faster alternative to AES-256 |
| Proton Pass | $4.99/mo billed monthly, or around $2.99/mo billed annually ($35.88/year) | Family bundle available for up to 6 users (pricing not publicly fixed — quoted at checkout) | AES-256, open-source clients, company based in Switzerland |
A caveat worth repeating: the 1Password, NordPass, and Proton Pass figures above include or are adjacent to promotional pricing that’s explicitly limited to new customers or specific term lengths — none of the three vendors publish a single, stable “this is what everyone pays” number the way Bitwarden does. Treat these as a starting point for comparison, not a guarantee of what you’ll be charged a year from now, and check the live checkout price before committing to an annual plan.
The breakdown, tool by tool
1Password
What it’s for: people who want the most polished, “it just works” experience and are willing to pay a modest premium and accept there’s no free tier to fall back on.
Pros
- The Secret Key architecture adds a second, device-bound secret on top of your master password — even a full server breach wouldn’t be enough to decrypt vaults, since the key never touches 1Password’s servers
- Key derivation uses PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA256 at 650,000 iterations, a deliberately expensive process that makes brute-forcing a stolen vault impractical
- Family plan sharing, permissions, and recovery tools are generally considered the most refined in the category
- Published a public security white paper detailing the architecture, rather than just asserting “zero-knowledge” as a marketing line
Cons
- No free plan at all — if the tool doesn’t work out, there’s no fallback tier, only cancellation
- The advertised annual rate is explicitly a first-year, new-customer promotional price; the standard monthly rate ($3.99) is the more reliable number to budget around long-term
- Client apps are not open-source, so independent code audits rely on 1Password’s own commissioned reviews rather than public inspection
Bitwarden
What it’s for: anyone who wants the cheapest genuinely full-featured option, or specifically wants a password manager they (or their IT team) could audit or self-host.
Pros
- The entire codebase — apps, browser extensions, and server — is open source and publicly auditable on GitHub, which is a meaningfully different trust model than “trust our marketing”
- Self-hosting is available for people or organizations who don’t want to rely on Bitwarden’s cloud at all
- Cheapest paid tier in this comparison by a wide margin, and the free plan is genuinely usable long-term, not a crippled trial
- Families plan covers 6 accounts for less than what several competitors charge for a single Premium seat
Cons
- The interface is less visually polished than 1Password’s or NordPass’s — functional, not flashy
- Premium is billed annually only in the pricing shown; there’s no month-to-month option at the entry tier the way some competitors offer
- Advanced features (SSO, SCIM provisioning, access intelligence) are Enterprise-tier, aimed at organizations rather than individuals
Dashlane
What it’s for: users who want a password manager bundled with a VPN and don’t mind paying a bit more for that convenience.
Pros
- VPN access is bundled into paid plans, which can replace a separate VPN subscription for light use
- Dark web and scam alert monitoring is a genuine differentiator for users worried about credential leaks specifically
- Friends & Family plan covers up to 10 accounts under one subscription, more generous seat-wise than most Family tiers here
Cons
- No free plan since September 2025 — there’s no way to trial long-term the way you can with Bitwarden, NordPass, or Proton Pass
- Official pricing isn’t published as a plain figure on Dashlane’s own pricing pages (both the consumer and business pages show placeholder pricing that resolves dynamically); the numbers above are well-corroborated estimates, not a vendor-confirmed figure, so confirm the live price before subscribing
- Sits at the pricier end of this group for an individual plan
NordPass
What it’s for: people already using other Nord Security products (NordVPN, NordLayer) who want one vendor relationship, or anyone drawn to the newer XChaCha20 encryption approach.
Pros
- XChaCha20 is a modern, fast encryption cipher — a legitimate technical alternative to AES-256, not a downgrade
- Interface and autofill accuracy are frequently cited as some of the smoothest in the category
- Backed by Nord Security’s existing infrastructure and support organization, which is larger than most competitors here
Cons
- Pricing is the most opaque of the five — the list annual rate is rarely what new customers are actually shown, since term-length promotions (1-year vs. 2-year) shift the advertised number substantially, and the site doesn’t surface a plain “regular price” the way Bitwarden does
- The free plan’s one-device-at-a-time restriction is a real workflow limitation if you regularly switch between a phone and a laptop
- Family plan pricing, like the individual plan, varies by promotional term rather than having one fixed number
Proton Pass
What it’s for: privacy-conscious users who want a password manager from a company whose entire business (Proton Mail, Proton VPN, Proton Drive) is built around Swiss privacy law and open-source clients.
Pros
- Client apps are open-source, similar to Bitwarden’s trust model, and the company is based in Switzerland, which has favorable data-protection jurisdiction
- Free plan includes unlimited logins and 10 built-in email aliases for masked signups — a feature the other free tiers here don’t match
- Fits naturally into a Proton Unlimited bundle if you already use or are considering Proton Mail, VPN, or Drive
Cons
- The password manager is younger than the other four here, having launched years after 1Password, Dashlane, and Bitwarden — the feature set (especially around business/team administration) is less mature
- Pricing has moved more than once in the last couple of years as Proton has repositioned it, so the current annual rate is worth double-checking rather than assuming it’s stable
- Family bundle pricing isn’t published as a fixed figure and is presented at checkout rather than on the main pricing page
Which one fits your situation
Individual who wants the most polished experience and doesn’t mind paying for it: 1Password. The Secret Key model and refined sharing tools justify the price for people who’ll actually use the advanced features, but budget around the $3.99/mo standard rate, not the introductory annual discount.
Budget-conscious individual or anyone who wants an auditable, open-source tool: Bitwarden. It’s the cheapest genuinely full-featured option here, and the open-source codebase is a real trust advantage if that matters to you or your organization.
Household of up to 6 people wanting the lowest total cost: Bitwarden Families, at $3.99/mo billed annually for 6 accounts — the cheapest per-person family pricing in this comparison by a clear margin.
Anyone who wants a bundled VPN and doesn’t want to manage two subscriptions: Dashlane, with the caveat that there’s no free trial period to test the workflow first, so it’s worth trying a competitor’s free plan to confirm you like password-manager UX in general before committing.
Existing NordVPN or Nord Security customers: NordPass, mainly for the convenience of one vendor and one login — just don’t take the first advertised price as the number you’ll pay at renewal.
Privacy-focused users already in or considering the Proton ecosystem: Proton Pass, particularly if a Proton Unlimited bundle (Mail + VPN + Drive + Pass) is already on the table, since the marginal cost of adding the password manager is lower than buying it standalone.
None of these are irreversible choices — every one of the five supports exporting your vault, so switching later mainly costs you the time to re-organize folders and re-share items with family or teammates, not a locked-in subscription you’re stuck with.
Common questions
Is 1Password actually more secure than the free options? Not necessarily in a way that matters for most people. Bitwarden and Proton Pass both use industry-standard AES-256 encryption with a zero-knowledge architecture and are open-source, which is its own strong security argument. 1Password’s Secret Key adds a genuinely useful extra layer, but the practical security gap between “a well-implemented zero-knowledge free tool” and “a well-implemented zero-knowledge paid tool” is much smaller than the price difference implies.
Why don’t Dashlane, NordPass, and Proton Pass just publish a normal price? Some of it is standard SaaS behavior — testing pricing by region and by term length is common — but in this category specifically, it also reflects how promotion-driven customer acquisition has become. The practical response is the same regardless of the reason: check the actual checkout price for the term length you want before assuming the homepage number is what you’ll pay.
Can I import my passwords from my browser or another password manager? Yes, across all five. Every tool here supports importing from Chrome, Safari, Firefox, and most competing password managers via CSV or a direct import tool. This is a low-risk part of switching; the more time-consuming part is re-establishing sharing permissions for family or team members afterward.
Do I need the family plan, or can everyone just use my individual account? Sharing one login across a household defeats the purpose of the security model — nobody gets their own audit trail, recovery options, or private items separate from shared ones. Every vendor here explicitly builds family/sharing tiers around separate accounts with shared vaults for exactly this reason, and it’s worth paying for even in a two-person household.
Where to start
If there’s one piece of advice worth taking from all of this, it’s to start with whichever free plan is actually free — Bitwarden or Proton Pass — and use it for real for a week or two before paying for anything. Both give an honest read on whether password-manager workflows (browser extension prompts, mobile autofill, sharing a login with a family member) fit into daily use, without the pressure of a ticking trial countdown.
From there, the decision mostly comes down to whether the extra polish and Secret Key architecture in 1Password are worth its price to you, or whether Bitwarden’s open-source, lower-cost approach covers everything you actually need. Either way, start free, and check the live renewal price — not just the signup discount — before entering a card number for an annual plan.